Weigh up the options before bartering your writing services.
For most writers, getting paid to write means just that – money in the pocket. I’ve never advocated writing for free, but when is it ok to use the barter system?
Barter is something we often get into as kids. Perhaps we traded an hour spent washing the car for an extra hour of watching TV. With our friends, we almost certainly traded lunch items we didn’t want for ones we found more appealing, and also traded collectibles of all kinds. Human beings like to trade, but is writing for anything but mondy a sound business practice?
I have to be honest. In most cases, I go for the cash – a deposit up front and the rest on completion. Sometimes, though, barter can be worth it. Here are a few examples from my writing business.
Barter and My Writing Business – Case Studies
Case Study 1
A friend approached me to help get her WordPress website set up. We agreed a fee for the initial job (a slightly discounted mate’s rate, as we would call it in the UK) and started the job. However, it turned out to be a much longer job, partly because we kept refining what the site really needed. We also had some hosting and technical problems to sort out. Since I knew the budget was tight, I offered to do the rest of the job on a part cash, part services basis. She is a massage therapist, and I’ve got a pampering session booked in for some time in the next month. She got her site up and I get some self-care. Everyone wins.
Case Study 2
I had a meeting with a new client who was strapped for cash. However, he was upfront about it and wanted to compensate me. He offers business and organizational development courses. We agreed to swap a three day course for a package of writing services. That means I get some professional development which all of us need sometimes. Even better, I’m top of his list for payment for services when his next cash inflow comes.
Case Study 3
I once traded writing a promotional article for placement of my ad on a site where the ad fees would normally have been too high. The person who wanted the writing placed value on my writing services and I was happy with the ad placement and traffic I received in return.
Case Study 4
I run an ongoing promotion for a site that’s useful for writers on this blog in exchange for access to the daily job opportunity updates. I also promote the site wherever I can, as it’s a useful service. So far, we’re both happy with the arrangement.
How to Barter Successfully
So, yes, barter can work, but I don’t accept every offer. There are some important aspects to bartering successfully:
- First, you have to know the value of the services you want to trade. If you are a writer with a price list (even if it’s only in your head), then you know what you would expect to earn for writing an article, blog post or ebook. Keep that figure in mind when making a barter arrangement.
- Second, the other person has to have something that you want – and probably something that you wouldn’t normally buy, otherwise there’s no incentive for you.
- Third, you need to work out some equivalency. How much of your writing is worth how much of their product or service? You both have to be happy that there’s parity, otherwise one of you will end up feeling disgruntled.
- Fourth, only barter if you can live with the fact that you’re not getting cash on this occasion. Man – or woman – cannot live by barter alone. It might have been possible in the days before utility bills and cars, but it certainly isn’t now. Try bartering with the electricity company and you’ll see what I mean.
- Fifth, limit the arrangement. Most business people won’t want to barter forever. In the case of the second client I mentioned above, I stated clearly that while I was happy to barter in the short term, in the medium term I would expect to get paid so I could eat. He understood where I was coming from.
That’s my experience with barter – what’s yours? Have you learned any lessons you’d care to share?
This is my WordCarnival entry. Be sure to check out the other posts on the topic of barter – they will be great!
Photo credit: Sepehr Ehsani






{ 28 comments… read them below or add one }
Twitter: JamesSchipper
January 25, 2012 at 09:20
I’ve been using the barter system a lot lately. It really opens up some doors to things I wouldn’t have otherwise bought, and is just practice for my writing.
James Schipper wants you to read 5-Years Later: Making Life Better or Just Getting Older
Twitter: shurleyhall
January 25, 2012 at 09:25
It’s a good way to look at it, James. Using barter has helped me expand my skill set, which is never a bad thing.
Twitter: pjproductivity
January 25, 2012 at 09:49
Great post, Sharon – love the case studies and the pointers. I’m so happy bartering is growing in popularity – it’s a value-added proposition for both parties!
Annie Sisk (Pajama Productivity) wants you to read Barter Your Way to Biz+Life Brilliance
Twitter: shurleyhall
January 25, 2012 at 13:14
It certainly can be, Annie, if you manage it right.
Sharon,
I have rarely bartered directly, but I have bartered through a trade exchange for more than 30 years–first in my interior landscape business and now in my freelance writing business. I use my barter dollars for both business expenses and personal items. In the last couple of weeks, I’ve used barter dollars for accounting/tax work, haircuts, office machine repair, dental work, restaurant meals, and housecleaning. Barter has been very valuable to me, and I’ve done business with some of the same people for years. For example, I have used the same CPA for 25+ years, and have never paid him a penny in cash. Unfortunately, the IRS doesn’t take trade dollars.
And, of course, barter income is treated exactly as cash income for tax purposes, and business expenses paid in barter can be deducted just like those paid with cash.
Lillie Ammann wants you to read Now Choose Life, so That You and Your Children May Live
Twitter: shurleyhall
January 25, 2012 at 13:15
Thanks for sharing your examples, Lillie, and thanks also for the reminder about tax – something we all need to keep in mind.
Twitter: millercathy
January 25, 2012 at 12:25
Love the case studies examples. Most of us have been burned a time or two, but when I think about it, it was probably more my fault for ignoring my gut when approached. I will admit, I am hesitant to barter with someone I don’t know. That doesn’t mean that I have to know them personally, but I have to have established some kind of online relationship with them.
Do you find that to be true for yourself, Sharon?
Another example of bartering was one where I initiated it. I approached an organization I belong to that was having its annual conference. I asked to work the conference in exchange for waiving the fee (which was steep). I was pleasantly surprised when they agreed. It gave me great networking access.
Cathy Miller wants you to read The Pebble Effect That Causes Big-Time Business Problems
Twitter: shurleyhall
January 25, 2012 at 13:16
I always go with my gut, Cathy. I’ve learned from past mistakes that when I ignore it, I get burned. And yes, we have to have a relationship – it’s hard to trust that barter will work with someone you don’t know.
Twitter: NicoleAFende
January 25, 2012 at 15:41
Sharon I love the real life examples. They illustrate the variety of possible approaches and potential with business barter.
To follow up on Cathy’s comment regarding getting burned. Haven’t most people been burned by a so-called paying client? As a finance coach I can’t tell you the horror stories I hear about not getting paid. Cathy’s advice is spot on, trust your gut.
Nicole Fende wants you to read Is Your Biz Cash Low? Use Bartering to Grow!
Twitter: shurleyhall
January 25, 2012 at 18:35
You and Cathy are right, Nicole; paying clients can burn you too. I’ve never been burned on a barter arrangement, mostly because each party has control over what they contribute and when the arrangement should end.
Twitter: teasilvestre
January 25, 2012 at 16:02
Thanks for sharing your experiences! I think we learn more about something when we can use actual stories (like you did here).
For me, I try to limit bartering to items that I would use in my business (as opposed to personal services)…unless of course, that business matches my “ideal customer profile.” Their great testimonials (about me) are always needed!
Tea Silvestre wants you to read Build Your Brand and Your Business Without Cash (A True Story!)
Twitter: shurleyhall
January 25, 2012 at 18:37
Good point, Tea. If it’s a business transaction, then it makes sense to stick to business, though looking after your well-being is also good for business, no?
Twitter: graphicsbyevan
January 25, 2012 at 17:48
Great post, Sharon! i love the case studies and “how to” tips…i feel validated to have come up with similar guidelines, such as knowing the value of what you’re offering going in, and agreeing on the limits of the arrangment.
evan austin wants you to read Barter Smarter: Opportunities & Cautions
Twitter: shurleyhall
January 25, 2012 at 18:38
I had the same feeling when I read your post on barter, Evan. Looks like there’s a common set of guidelines for making the arrangement work.
Twitter: eugenefarber
January 25, 2012 at 18:55
I love that you provide real-life case studies from personal experience. A true testament to the barter system (if you can find the appropriate person to work with!).
Eugene Farber wants you to read Selling by Putting Your Faults on Display: A Mini Case Study
Twitter: shurleyhall
January 26, 2012 at 09:33
Life’s funny like that, Eugene – opportunities just come up. I don’t often go looking for barter arrangements, but if a good one arises, I’m open to it. And, thanks to this series of posts, I’ve got some great resources for exploring barter more intensely.
Twitter: ImNickArmstrong
January 25, 2012 at 20:58
“Fifth, limit the arrangement. Most business people won’t want to barter forever.”
This is usually the most difficult thing. There’s very few ways to go from barter to paid work with someone; they almost always expect a pro-bono downgrade or to work with someone new.
It depends on who you’re bartering with, obviously, but most of the time, that time-limit is the deciding factor on whether or not it will be a successful barter.
Great post!
Twitter: shurleyhall
January 26, 2012 at 09:34
True, Nick. I think setting expectations up front helps otherwise the transition might not be smooth.
Twitter: virtuallyassist
January 26, 2012 at 00:22
Love the case studies too! I also like the tip of having a time arrangement up front…definitely can see a benefit to that.
Michelle Church wants you to read Bartering Increases Business Opportunities
Twitter: shurleyhall
January 26, 2012 at 09:35
Well, we don’t usually have open ended business arrangements, Michelle, so why should a barter arrangement be any different?
Twitter: annewayman
January 26, 2012 at 19:27
Oh this is a good one Sharon… I rarely barter. In fact I can’t remember when… but I’m about to barter a conversation about setting up a blog for some emotional healing.
Also love the ‘mate rate.’ I have one of those but have never had a name for it.
Anne Wayman wants you to read The Sky Is Bluer Than Usual Today
Twitter: shurleyhall
January 26, 2012 at 19:46
That should be an interesting trade, Anne. Unfortunately, barter doesn’t always pay the bills, but it can have some benefits, I’ve found. I don’t know that I would choose it as my first option, though it’s good to be flexible – you never know what opportunities might turn up.
Twitter: thedankeller
January 26, 2012 at 21:48
I have been bartering online and offline frequently as well. I own a resume writing company and charge several hundred dollars for a resume. I have had several people approach me and ask for a reduction or free resume in exchange for services. Just last week, I bartered for a used laptop computer that I gave to my daughter.
Dan Keller wants you to read Boost your Productivity with these 5 Amazing Apps for Android
Twitter: shurleyhall
January 26, 2012 at 22:22
Sounds like a useful trade, Dan.
Bartering does work. I have built a business around bartering services and it pays off. If the deal is a fair one both parties win.
Twitter: katiepecbvda
January 30, 2012 at 14:13
Case 1 sounds like a great deal. I would definitely write for massages in return instead of money. lol.
Katie Woodard wants you to read Bow Wow – Do It to the Fullest and 5 Fingers of Death Freestyle – Download
Twitter: shurleyhall
January 30, 2012 at 15:00
I am fairly new to blogging and trying to earn a nickel from it. I have found in my short blogging “career” that doing some guest posts on others sites simply for backlinks and possible traffic is a nice way to get some free promotion. Thanks for the article:)