How do you feel when you receive negative feedback?
I recently received some feedback from a client about how a piece of work I had submitted had a few typos and grammatical errors in it.
When I received the feedback, my first reaction was to be protective of my work and think that the feedback must have been wrong or I’d used a British word which wouldn’t have been understood properly by an American audience.
Then when I checked the piece and realised I had made some errors, I felt annoyed and to a certain extent, embarrassed.
But, in all honesty, I wasn’t overly surprised – I’ve been writing for 3 years now and this was the first piece of negative feedback I’ve received. I’ve produced work for a range of different clients in a variety of different styles and I’ve managed for over 3 years to not receive a piece of negative feedback.
That’s not to say I wasn’t angry, upset and embarrassed. Plus, there was a bit of worry in there, too – as soon as I received the feedback, I started questioning my work in general and myself as a writer, worrying whether the mistake I’d made was going to have such a negative effect on my relationship with the client that they were going to stop hiring me as a writer.
Although the feedback hit me quite hard, I was surprised with myself at how I acted.
I was expecting to be a little irrational, but I managed to keep my head and put into practice the 3 steps I’d researched and put together for when a time like this occurred.
First, I let myself have a few minutes being annoyed and feeling down over the mistakes
As I’ve mentioned in previous posts, I’m a positive person. When you get told you’ve made a mistake, though, you naturally feel annoyed and upset and although you can mask these feelings initially, they’re going to come out sooner or later, so just let them out straight away.
Don’t go spending days worrying about a typo or two, but allow the negative feelings to get out of your system before you do anything else.
I then looked at why I’d made the errors
Was it because I was busy and didn’t have time to check or edit properly? Was I just being lazy and couldn’t be bothered to double check my work? Or was it because editing isn’t my favourite part of being a freelance writer?
I came to the conclusion that it was a combination of the first and third reasons. Things have been particularly hectic for me over the past 6 weeks and I think I let the things that I don’t particularly enjoy slip somewhat.
The final step I took was to look at how these mistakes could be prevented in the future
My initial reaction in this instance was to simply take more time proofing and editing. It’s not something I particularly enjoy, but it’s part of being a writer and so I should dedicate more time to it.
However, I then considered hiring a professional editor to look through all of my work before I send it to clients. I researched this a little more and realised that it’s a fantastic option and whilst I’m not going to hire a professional editor at the moment (I want to know that I can effectively edit my own work, rather than ignoring the fact it’s one of my weak points), it’s definitely something I’m going to look at in the future.
What’s more, as discussed in my recent post ‘Are You Writing In The Most Efficient Way Possible?‘, I’m going to stick with editing after writing each individual piece. Proofing and editing a large batch of work at once might work for some, but it really doesn’t work for me.
I think what every writer has to realise is that they’re going to make mistakes at some point throughout their career. No matter how much you check your work or how proficient you become as a writer, chances are you’re going to make the occasional typo.
The point you have to remember is that you’re only human. Mistakes are never good and if you make them regularly, they’re going to have a detrimental effect on both you as a writer and your relationship with your clients. But no one is going to hang you out to dry over the occasional misspelled word or grammatical mistake, no matter how much it may feel like they will at the time.
Do you find proofing and editing a difficult thing to do? Have you ever been in a situation where making a mistake has had a big effect on your career? Has poor proofing cost you client or have your excellent editing skills landed you a gig?
Image: Samat Jain (Flickr)






{ 11 comments }
I’m not proud of it, but there have been occasions when client feedback has made me cry. It’s tough to put so much effort into your work and get back feedback that tears it down. But it’s a fact of life: you’re absolutely correct in pointing out that writers have to remember that we’re human and we make mistakes. We have to realize that criticism isn’t personal.
Thursday Bram wants you to read Productivity and Creativity- A Toolbox to Improve Your Work
I can completely understand how you may have been in tears because of feedback.
I wasn’t at the point where I was crying in this instance, but I was shocked at just how much the feedback affected me and the number of different emotions that I felt because of it.
And that’s a fantastic point – the feedback isn’t personal. It’s on the piece of writing, not you as an individual and once you realise this, accepting feedback becomes a whole lot easier.
Dan Smith wants you to read Do You Keep Your Best Ideas For Yourself Or Your Clients
Twitter: shurleyhall
September 8, 2010 at 11:46
Years ago, when I was working in magazines, a major typo slipped through on my watch (I didn’t proof the piece, but I was responsible for the issue). I was extremely embarrassed, and it made me check work even more rigorously. I never had that trouble again at that publication.
When most of your work gets positive reviews, the occasional piece of criticism can really hit you hard – it does when it happens to me. But since it’s my job to provide polished and professional writing, I follow the steps you outline and avoid reacting immediately with a defensive response.
I think what makes the situation worse is that you have to deal with a whole host of different emotions.
If someone does something that you don’t like, you get annoyed.
If someone says something that’s hurtful, you get upset.
If someone tells you that you’ve made a massive faux pas, you get embarrassed.
But if someone says something negative about something you’ve done, you feel all three at once (or in quick succession), meaning you don’t just have one emotion to contend with, but three.
In the example you provided, Sharon, was there any comeback on you, even though you weren’t responsible for the proofing?
Twitter: shurleyhall
September 9, 2010 at 15:05
Well, I felt annoyed, upset and embarrassed, my boss (the managing editor) and I had to apologise to the head of department (the person affected by the typo). That was enough to make me (and the person who had actually made the error) extra careful from then on.
Hi Sharon,
I really needed this post. I recently completed a rather frustrating, low-paid project filled with unpaid rewrites and conflicting guidance. Even though I made every effort to accommodate the client, he still gave me unfair and overly critical feedback on my online profile. (And I NEVER get bad feedback.)
For me, the lesson is: “Don’t work for that client again.” Sometimes as writers, we are at fault for making mistakes, but some clients just aren’t reasonable – no matter how hard you try, they’ll never be happy. This makes it all the more important to cherish the good clients!
Ben Gran wants you to read The lows of freelancing
That’s one of the things that riles me as a freelance writer – I don’t mind if writers take on projects that don’t pay as much as they should, but it’s the fact that the clients often assume that they can be as critical or expect to have several unpaid revisions as if they were paying the going rate.
You get what you pay for – it’s a simple fact throughout life.
It’s good that you walked away, Ben. Too many writers just breaking into the industry (and even a few who are established in it) are too concerned that they’ll never replace they work from the client that they continue to pander to their every whim.
If you’re a decent writer, you’ll replace the client and the work – and you’ll feel a whole lot better for doing it.
Dan Smith wants you to read Do You Keep Your Best Ideas For Yourself Or Your Clients
Hi Sharon, I made a typo on a caption I wrote in my first job, and I have never forgotten it. Even though I was in my 20′s, I remember that I had a pretty sophisticated way of deconstruction why it happened. It was a complicated last name, and I was in a hurry to help the editor go to press on a story. It was not a great situation, as this individual had provided our business with a small grant (yipes!) but we put in a correction and to this day I always double check names in particular. You are totally right in your reaction – people forget that writers are human, and I’ve been really surprised at the number of typos and other grammatical erros I’ve seen in the past few years, by those who are professional writers!
I usually thank them for helping point out something I can attend to to make me a better writer. Spelling mistakes usually only slip through the cracks, as you rightly said, because of lack of proper editing.
One day my boss kindly wrote ma an email to check spelling in my emails, because to check for them, as he said it, ‘is really a small thing’.
Best advice ever!
Enjoy your day everyone

Ivin wants you to read Advantages and Disadvantages of Self Publishing
Twitter: danaprince
September 9, 2010 at 13:35
It stings when you realise you’ve messed up. Once I get over the initial dread I really do try to learn something from it. Of course it’s awesomest (that’s a word, right? lol) when clients gush about how great of a job I’ve done but I’d rather hear the negative than have them just fade off and never give me another chance.
Dana wants you to read Freelance Writer Marketing Tips- Get Traffic to Your Professional Writing Website
Twitter: shurleyhall
September 9, 2010 at 15:06
I agree, Dana, it’s better to get the feedback so you can fix things.